Skip to Content

Food Fail Friday, Episode #1

I’ve been keeping something from you.

Something that takes a lot of time, prevents me from posting here, and sometimes makes me cry.

Want to know the secret?

My recipe fails!

…Was that too dramatic?

As I was sorting through recent pictures of my “failures,” I remembered that the whole point of this blog was to talk about my trial and error process.

I’m by no means an expert and I have a lot of learning to do. When I get it right, I love to share it with you. But I was stuck in the mode of thinking that I had to get it right before I could talk about what went wrong, and that’s not always practical.

I’m calling this the first episode of “Food Fail Friday” simply because well, it’s Friday. But this won’t an every Friday thing… if I had enough food fails for a weekly post, I’d really cry. But if you like seeing this kind of behind the scenes action, let me know!

Now, on to the #foodfails – I’ll leave you with 10 for now, but trust me that I’ve got more.

“Sumbitches” cookies. If you’ve seen the last season of the show How I Met Your Mother, you know what I’m talking about. I didn’t have caramel candy so I tried it with caramel sauce. Things looked fine going into the oven…

tried and failed sumbitches cookies

But proceeded to become one big sticky blob. Also, terrible lighting.

tried and failed sumbitches cookies

I’ll stick to cookies like pomegranate chocolate chip cookies, key lime cookies and oatmeal lace cookies.

Pumpkin Coconut Quinoa

Looks as bad as it sounds. It was one of those nights I just kept throwing things in the pot… surprisingly I ate it, but regretted it later.

tried and failed pumpkin coconut quinoa

Quinoa is much better in veggie salad or casserole.

Brussel sprouts. So much burning.

burnt brussels sprouts

Luckily I have since figured out lemon brussels sprouts, bang bang brussels sprouts, and maple sprouts.

Meringue candy canes. When I was in high school, I once spent a whole day making 8 different kinds of cookies to give my friends a “variety pack” of goodies for their Christmas present. My cousins were taste testers, and I always remembered that they loved these meringue candy canes. 

So, 10 years later I tried to recreate them and just ended up wasting a lot of eggs and food coloring. So sticky, and maybe I just don’t like meringue.

meringue candy canes

I’ll stick to peppermint cookies.

Chocolate pizza. CHOCOLATE. PIZZA. How could this go so wrong? But it did.

chocolate pizza tried and failed

Drinking my chocolate from now on.

Blood Orange Curd. I thought I was being so clever with this one, replacing lemon juice with blood oranges. But it ended up chunky and not at all the right consistency. Also a friend thought it was peanut butter (by appearance, not taste).

blood orange curd tried and failed

The flavor is, however, delicious in these blood orange waffles.

Chocolate Peanut Butter Granola Bars. I can’t believe anything Chocolate + PB is making it to the failed list, but I think I chipped a tooth on these.

chocolate peanut butter granola bars tried and failed

Vegan Apple Cinnamon Scones. AKA sawdust.

vegan apple cinnamon scones tried and failed

Peach scones turned out much better.

Sriracha & blood orange salad dressing. This was another from blood orange day. The photo shoot went something like this: stir stir stir *take a picture* stir stir *crap it’s still separated* stir. I don’t know if it’s even fair to say it didn’t taste good because it just wouldn’t combine.

Sriracha & blood orange salad dressing

Relish. I was trying to recreate that time I once made a really good chunky relish (and lost the recipe). The below is not it. This linked relish is the one!

relish tried and failed

How do you deal with your food fails, friends?

Would you like to save this?

We'll email this post to you, so you can come back to it later!
You'll also get email updates with new recipes (you can opt-out any time).

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Terri B

Saturday 10th of February 2024

I see this is a (last updated April 2015) with posts & pics but it made me lmao! I’ve had many failures…… just this morning I decided to use the egg yolks I had leftover from a previous recipe (whites only) in my Saturday morning pancakes. They cook really fast so the first 4 were burnt on one side. This cook/baker happily eats her mistakes and/or failures. Luckily I have a wonderful husband who loves to oblige me and eat my mistakes also. There’s only been a couple instances where he has said “You don’t have to make that again!” Love.This.Man. After my ‘cakes debacle this morning your post just made my day!

Lauren @ ihadabiglunch

Monday 6th of April 2015

I think this is why I could never be a food blogger in the sense that you are. I don't have the time, patience, money, or emotional stamina to have epic foodie fails haha. I love that you shared this, though! It's a reminder that recipes take so much effort to perfect, and that you're human.

B.sprouts burn SO EASILY! I totally related to that one haha.

Kelly

Tuesday 7th of April 2015

Sometimes I run out of patience too, which is why I thought it would be good for me to share some of these :) Thanks for the feedback! I'm hoping my food fails decrease over time but it is definitely frustrating!

Meredith

Saturday 4th of April 2015

Those Brussels sprouts actually look good to me, ha ha! :) When I have a food fail, I just say, "Never again" and move on. I don't want to waste my time trying to perfect something that tasted awful.

Kelly

Tuesday 7th of April 2015

I still ate them! But just didn't work out for what I had planned for them. Food fails are the worst.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.